DIALECT®Begin a Project

API integration or MCP?

The choice depends on what starts the work and how people need to interact with the connected system.

A company may describe two requests as “connecting our systems” even though the jobs are quite different. One team wants approved records transferred to another application every night. Another wants to ask an AI application questions about those records and carry out a limited set of actions.

Both projects can involve APIs. MCP, the Model Context Protocol, adds a standard interface through which a compatible AI application can use capabilities exposed by a server. It may sit in front of an existing API rather than replace it.

A scheduled transfer needs a reliable trigger and a record of what completed. An interactive connection also needs to show the person what they can request and which actions require approval.

Conventional API integrations

A conventional integration can move information or perform a defined operation when a schedule, event, or user action starts the process. An order might need to appear in an operations system, or an approved item might need to update another record.

The integration needs to map the fields between systems and record whether each operation completed. Repeated requests, missing information, and unavailable services need an appropriate response. An integration should not leave the company guessing whether an action happened.

Where the process is predictable, introducing an AI interface may add no useful capability. The team can use the established workflow and reserve interactive assistance for work that benefits from it.

MCP connections

MCP's server concepts describe tools, resources, and prompts. A server can expose capabilities such as retrieving information or requesting an operation, which a compatible application can then use.

A possible business use is allowing a person to retrieve information from an approved system while working in an AI application. Another is preparing a proposed change for review. The server can limit the available operations to those required for that work.

Our guide to custom MCP development explores the scope of that work. The existence of a protocol does not settle the business's access requirements or the responsibilities for each action.

Permissions and approvals

Either approach needs to operate under appropriate permissions. The design should identify whose access applies, what can be read, and what can be changed. Sensitive capabilities should use established authentication and authorization mechanisms.

The interface also needs to make outcomes understandable. A user should be able to tell whether a request succeeded, failed, or needs further review. Where an action requires approval, that requirement has to be implemented in the operating process.

These decisions belong in the project brief before development begins, alongside the systems and people involved.

Maintenance and team training

The company needs a maintenance arrangement whichever approach it chooses. APIs, permissions, and application behavior can change. Someone should be responsible for checking that the connection continues to perform the agreed job and for responding when it does not.

The connection may also need implementation and training within the team. Our guide to AI workflow rollout explains that surrounding work. The people operating the connection need to know which tasks it supports and how to continue when it is unavailable.