Comparing a monthly retainer with an executive salary gives a company only part of the hiring decision. The roles may involve different amounts of time, different responsibilities, and different support from the rest of the team.
A fractional CMO can take responsibility for marketing direction within an agreed allocation of time. A full-time CMO has a broader daily presence in the company, although that alone does not determine which tasks they personally perform. In either arrangement, the business still needs people to produce and operate the marketing.
Before comparing fees, describe a normal week in the role. Include staff supervision and meetings with other departments, as well as the decisions that cannot wait until the following week.
Daily responsibilities
A relatively small team may have experienced people who can work independently from an agreed plan. Its senior marketing needs could center on allocation, positioning, supplier direction, and periodic reviews. That can make a fractional arrangement practical.
A company with several business units, frequent launches, and a large team may require continuous executive involvement. The CMO may spend substantial time hiring, developing managers, working with finance, and negotiating priorities with other departments. Trying to compress that job into a few days a month can leave important decisions unattended.
There is no revenue threshold that resolves this for every company. The complexity and frequency of the work matter. Our article on when to hire a fractional CMO looks at how to identify the leadership gap before selecting the arrangement.
The people around the CMO
A fractional leader depends on a team that can carry agreed work forward between their scheduled days. If the internal marketer needs daily supervision, the engagement may require more time or an additional management role. The proposal should make that dependency clear.
A full-time executive also depends on delivery capacity. Hiring the executive while leaving no budget for creative, media, research, or specialist support can produce a well-led function with too little ability to execute. The marketing team structure and the leadership appointment should be considered together.
The full cost of each appointment
The company needs to compare the whole arrangement over a realistic period. For an employee, that includes the applicable employment costs and the support the role requires. For a fractional engagement, it includes the agreed fee, any separate delivery work, and the internal time needed to operate the relationship.
A lower fee does not settle the question if it purchases too little availability. Equally, a full-time appointment may leave the company paying for capacity it cannot yet use. Our guide to fractional CMO costs explains why proposals need to be compared by scope as well as price.
Continuity and handover
A fractional engagement can continue while the company builds its team, or it can form part of a transition to a full-time hire. The company should be clear about whether recruitment and handover are included. A leader appointed during a vacancy may have a different remit from one building a function from the beginning.
Whichever arrangement is chosen, decisions and working knowledge need to remain accessible to the company. Supplier relationships, budgets, and account access should survive the departure of one person. Before the appointment, agree how that information will be kept and handed over.