DIALECT®Begin a Project

How to choose a paid media agency

The proposal should make it clear who will manage the account, what the agency will deliver, and how the company will judge the work.

Two agencies can propose managing the same advertising budget and offer substantially different services. One may include strategy, creative production, and landing page work. Another may focus on buying and optimization, relying on the client to supply everything needed to run the campaigns.

The difference may be sensible, but it needs to be visible before the appointment. Otherwise the company discovers the gaps when a campaign is waiting for assets or a reporting problem requires work outside the retainer.

Before choosing an agency, meet the people who will manage the account and ask them to explain a relevant piece of work. The result will be easier to judge when you know what they changed and what the client supplied.

Case studies and results

A reported return needs context. The company should understand the period measured, the conversion being counted, and whether the result concerns new customers, existing customers, or a mixture. A strong promotion or an established brand can influence the result alongside the agency's work.

The discussion should establish what the agency actually changed and which parts of the program it controlled. A case study may demonstrate a relevant skill without predicting the result for another business. Our article on ROAS and marketing efficiency explains some of the distinctions behind these figures.

The account team

The pitch team may have different responsibilities from the people assigned to the account. Before signing, the company should understand who leads the work, who manages the campaigns, and how senior support is involved when the account needs a decision.

Availability should reflect the pace of the business. A company with frequent product changes may need a different review arrangement from one with a stable offer. The agency should be able to explain how it receives information, handles urgent requests, and records changes.

Fees and scope

The scope needs to address measurement and creative work as well as media buying. If tracking needs repair, someone must be responsible for investigating and implementing it. If new assets are required every month, the company needs to know who produces them and what the fee includes.

The agreement should also explain fees, media payments, and any additional production or technology costs. Access to accounts and ownership of work need to remain clear if the relationship ends. Where several suppliers contribute, the company needs a plan for coordinating their work.

An initial paid media audit can help define the scope, provided its conclusions distinguish observed problems from proposals that still need testing.

Reporting and the first review

The agency and company should agree what the program is trying to accomplish and which evidence will support decisions. Platform reports can guide campaign management, while the business review considers sales quality, costs, and the wider commercial position.

The first review needs to allow for setup, production, and the time customers take to act. Where the appointment includes a new channel, a defined test budget and review plan helps both sides understand what the initial spending can establish. Include that review date and the agreed measures in the proposal.