DIALECT®Begin a Project

How to hire a fractional CMO

A portfolio shows past work. The interview needs to establish what the candidate did and how they would handle the job you are offering.

Senior marketing candidates can have impressive portfolios that reveal little about how they would operate in a particular company. A successful launch at a well-funded business may have relied on resources the next employer does not have. A strong adviser may also prefer a different kind of role from one that involves managing staff and suppliers.

The company can improve the conversation by describing the unresolved work before asking for a proposal. Perhaps the founder wants to hand over agency management. Perhaps the team needs a plan for a new market. Those situations call for different experience and different amounts of time.

A short written brief gives candidates enough context to explain how they would approach the role. It also gives the company a consistent basis for comparing them.

Relevant experience

When a candidate presents a result, ask them to describe their contribution. They may have decided which market to enter, managed the agency, or inherited a successful campaign. Knowing who made the decisions and who produced the work makes the result easier to assess.

Relevant experience can concern the company's business model, stage, or specific problem. A candidate does not need to have worked for an identical company, but should be able to explain which lessons transfer and which assumptions need checking. References can add detail about how the person worked with founders, employees, and other partners.

Discussing a real business problem

The interview can explore one problem already described in the brief without asking the candidate to produce an unpaid strategy. The company can ask what information they would want, which people they would speak with, and what might cause them to change their initial view.

A thoughtful response may contain uncertainty. A candidate who has not seen the underlying figures should have questions about them. Listen to how they weigh the information available and explain what they would need to check before recommending a change.

Comparing the proposals

The proposals need to identify the work included in the fee and the work that needs additional people or spending. Managing a creative supplier is different from supplying the creative team. The distinction between fractional marketing and a fractional CMO is particularly important when a provider offers both.

Time and authority also need to be explicit. The company should understand the scheduled commitment, availability between meetings, and the decisions the CMO can make. If the role includes people management, recruitment, or agency replacement, those responsibilities should appear in the agreement.

Comparing the proposals against the same brief will expose differences more clearly than comparing the headline monthly fees. The cost guide explains the scope differences that can sit behind those fees.

The first review and handover

The first review should be defined before the work starts. Both sides need to know what the opening period is intended to establish, what the company will provide, and which decisions remain with the founder. Our article on the first 90 days describes a possible approach.

The agreement should also explain handover and the end of the engagement. The company needs continuing access to its accounts and work, with a clear record of decisions. Put those handover obligations in the agreement before work begins.